[monikahelden]

Any one look at the game of 4 players game , Iwantparkplace,redhool,m2gn2te,key6
In all over the trades we change site to be fair and give advantage to both.
I have 2 brown and 1 red, redhool have the complementary.
I send to change site with fair cash , but Don't think located in a trap to sell 3rd brown and 3rd red to have 1700.
Was a trap and asked redhool to retrieve his cheating offer but he reject.
Was a trap , hope if any one look and decide.
Game ended immediately.
I'm playing as key6.

[trace567]

I've checked both the trades offers and accepted along with the full chat log of the game.

First I will comment on the trade offered to red by key prior to the trade key accepted in error.

The trade offered by Key6 to redhool was as follows:

Taking 2100 cash 2 brown (making a set) 1 orange which doesn't make a set.
Giving - 1 red of which makes a set for redhool

This trade was NOT accepted.

I do feel that this trade was perhaps a little over priced, as in gaining browns and also 2100 cash. Start was at 120.
This would leave redhool with just under 1300 cash to build reds. However key6 would gain brown to upgrade instantly and cash left over to possibly trade with.

This I feel was a trade that whilst NOT a cheat, is pushing towards borderline.

Now on the the actual trade that was accepted.

Key asked in the chat to please reverse. He also sent the reverse offer to redhool in an attempt to have it reversed.

The trade was as follows:

redhool to key6
Giving 1700 cash and 1 orange (of which was only good if could trade)
Taking brown and red both making a set.

This left red with 1800 cash to start building. The board was very empty at this stage with no significant sets or outgoings in place.

This left key6 with cash and a pretty useless orange. He could only go further within the game by trading with another player for a set. Only this would leave him low on cash to do so and no current income.

Therefore the accepted trade is not very good, and I will say it is certainly on the side of a cheat trade as it did not give key6 hardly any advancing, yet gave redhool a huge gain of 2 sets (brown and red).

As key6 clearly attempted and asked to have the trade reversed I will not make any point reduction on this player.

Redhool however will receive -50% point reduction for the sending of a cheat trade of which he then refused to reverse when it had been accepted.

Key6 also please do keep an eye on your own trade offers, as some are not so good.

[monikahelden]

I read your's reply 7 times.
This game will be safe if someone is looking with open eyes.
Trace, As you asked me to change my account poiand wich I played poLand,I would like to change it to key7.

[trace567]

[monikahelden]

New account key7 created.

[trace567]

[monikahelden]

I loggedin key7.

[trace567]